How the comparison is built
Inside IR35 (umbrella): the whole assignment income goes to the umbrella company. It deducts its margin, employer NI at 15% above £5,000 and the 0.5% apprenticeship levy, and pays the rest as your salary under PAYE.
Outside IR35 (limited company): your company invoices the client, pays expenses, pays you a salary of £12,570 (enough for a State Pension qualifying year with no employee NI), pays corporation tax on the profit, and distributes what is left as dividends. Corporation tax is 19% on profits up to £50,000, 25% above £250,000, with marginal relief in between.
Worked example: £500 a day for 220 days
£500 a day, 220 days, £3,000 company expenses, 2026/27
The contract is worth £110,000 a year. Inside IR35 the umbrella’s costs reduce the salary to around £95,000, and after PAYE tax and NI you keep £65,650. Outside IR35, after corporation tax and dividend tax, you keep £68,515.
- Inside IR35 take-home
- £65,650via umbrella
- Difference per year
- £2,865
- Contract value
- £110,000
Inside IR35 (umbrella PAYE)
- Assignment income
- £110,000.00
- Umbrella margin
- −£1,040.00
- Employer NI
- −£13,498.05
- Apprenticeship levy (0.5%)
- −£474.94
- Gross salary
- £94,987.01
- Income tax
- −£25,426.80
- Employee NI
- −£3,910.34
- Take-home
- £65,649.87
Outside IR35 (limited company)
- Company income
- £110,000.00
- Expenses
- −£3,000.00
- Director salary (£12,570) + employer NI
- −£13,705.50
- Corporation taxwith marginal relief
- −£20,973.04
- Dividends paid out
- £72,321.46
- Dividend tax
- −£16,376.17
- Take-home (salary + dividends)
- £68,515.29
What changed for 2026/27
The higher dividend rates (10.75% and 35.75%) narrow the gap between inside and outside IR35 slightly. Employer NI at 15% with a £5,000 threshold, introduced in April 2025, continues to weigh heavily on umbrella rates. Corporation tax rates are unchanged.
Tips
- Negotiate the rate on status. An inside-IR35 role at the same day rate pays far less; many contractors ask for 20–30% more.
- Check the umbrella’s figures. Compare the “gross salary” on your payslip with the assignment rate to see what came off before tax.
- Challenge a wrong determination through the client’s disagreement process within 45 days.
- Outside IR35, keep evidence of substitution rights, control and financial risk in your contract and in practice.